Saturday, December 29, 2012

How might one analyze the essay "A Dialogue on Democracy," by A. S. Hornby?

A. S. Hornby’s “A Dialogue of Democracy” is a brief work
in which a young couple, Jack and Anne, discuss the different ways in which the word
“democracy” can be (and has been) defined. Among those ways are the
following:


  • The American system of government,
    with a President and Congress. This system gives the President great
    powers.

  • The British system of government, with a
    Prime Minister and Parliament. This system limits the power of the Prime
    Minister.

  • The ancient Athenian system of
    government – a democracy in which free persons nevertheless owned
    slaves.

  • A system, such as that in Britain, in
    which civil servants seem both powerful and limited in their
    power.

  • A system, such as that in Britain, in
    which Members of Parliament are elected by the people but are told how to vote by party
    leaders.

  • A system, such as that in Britain, in
    which the people can replace one government with another if they choose but in which
    elections can be delayed for years by the party in
    power.

  • A system in which people often vote in
    their own self-interests, even when they do not understand many issues on which they are
    voting.

  • A system in which at least two parties
    compete against each other.

  • A system involving
    “People’s Democracies,” in which much property is owned by the
    state.

  • A system in which the people are free to
    criticize the government.

  • A system in which all
    people can vote but in which various kinds of inequalities still
    exist.

  • A system in which people regard one
    another as equals and address one another as
    equals.

As Jack appropriately exclaims
in the very last sentence of the work,


readability="5">

How difficult it is to get a definition
for this word!


No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...