Thursday, August 7, 2014

Describe the role of female characters in "The Garden Party", "Miss Brill", "The Little Governess" and "Her First Ball" by Katherine Mansfield.

This is a big question relating to four very different
short stories, so my answer is going to be necessarily brief. I will point towards
general patterns rather than specifics, and this will hopefully enable you to return to
these four excellent stories and analyse them
further.


Katherine Mansfield is an author who is rightfully
famous for the way in which she is able to depict the limited position of women in a
patriarchal sphere. Often she is able to do this incredibly poignantly, as in "Miss
Brill," where the title character is really shown to have such an empty life, devoid of
joy and human companionship. This is indicated when Miss Brill returns home to "her room
like a cupboard" alone and saddened, after having had to imagine all sorts of things to
make herself believe that she is significant and
needed.


"The Little Governess" again is another story that
reinforces this central idea. The way in which the governess is only refered to as the
"little" governess emphasises her lack of strength and power, and as the story
progresses we see that she is subject both to male power and also she is economically
dependent on Frau Arnholdt for a job. She is abroad for the first time, and thus weak
and vulnerable in every sense.


"The Garden Party" seems to
emphasise the naivety of Laura at the beginning of the story through the way that she is
blind to the impact of class. Her shock at the death of Mr. Scott and her desire to
cancel the garden party results in her being reprimanded by her mother and scorned by
her sister. It is only at the end of the story, when she goes to pay her respects and
sees the corpse of Mr. Scott that she experiences an epiphany that comments directly
about the value of her frivolous life.


Lastly, "Her First
Ball" depicts the way in which growing up is a very ambivalent experience, tempered as
it is by both excitement and joy and also an increasing awareness of the ephemeral
nature of youth and beauty. Leila's response to the fat man's comments and her desire to
leave the ball reflect the latter, whilst her return to the dancing and her forgetting
of the old man indicate the former.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...