Monday, June 30, 2014

What is the point of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas?

I think that "the point" in Boyne's work is multifold.  On
one hand, he seeks to provide a child's view towards the Holocaust.  The Holocaust is a
time period of such intense cruelty and violation of human trust that to place focus on
it from the frame of reference of a child is extremely powerful.  Boyne is able to bring
this out through Bruno's characterization.  From his beliefs on right and wrong to his
mispronunciation of "Auschwitz" and "The Fuhrer" ("Out- With" and "The Fury"), we see
the Holocaust through his eyes and this allows us to fully understand the inhumanity of
the Holocaust and its inversion of human values from a child's point of
view.


Another "point" in the book is to bring out a level
of humanity in the German people.  It is a difficult task to humanize a nation that has
to bear the moral responsibility for one of the worst crimes ever perpetrated in human
history.  In all honesty, how does one bring out the humanity in a people that voted
Hitler into office and zealously supported him when he made no concealment of his
overall purpose of extermination?  Boyne is able to bring out the element of the German
population that either did not support Hitler and were silenced because of it or the
part of the population that was ambivalent about what was happening and found themselves
unable to say anything about it for different reasons.  For example, Bruno's grandmother
speaks out against Bruno's father for his involvement in the Nazi party, insulting him
and his "costume."  Bruno's sister comes to represent the part of the German population
that supported the Nazis because of their social status and "popularity."  Yet, when
faced with the atrocity of Bruno's death, she is inconsolable with sadness.  Bruno's
father comes to reverse his position on what is happening when he experiences its cost
firsthand when his child is a victim.  In this, Boyne does not excuse the Germans, but
he brings about a transcendent level of humanity whereby true understanding and a sense
of moral reconciliation can occur.  This is a difficult thing to do and Boyne
accomplishes it well.


Finally, the notion of transcendence
and permanence in a time period of brutal contingency is another "point" to the work. 
Boyne points out that friendship and loyalty are universal qualities, ones that have to
be embraced in the worst of times for this speaks to their essential qualities to human
consciousness.  Bruno crosses the fence and wants to go back home.  Yet, Shmuel reminds
him of his promise, and Bruno stands by his word.  In a time period where so few honored
the bonds between themselves and others, Bruno and Shmuel are the exceptions in proving
the importance of universal qualities regardless of circumstance.  Bruno's last words to
Shmuel while in the gas chamber are that Shmuel is his “best friend for life.”  In the
moment of unspeakable horror and terror, when the metallic clang is the last thing heard
except for the screams of the naked bodies all around, Bruno speaks words of comfort to
his friend.  This is where the ultimate "point" of the work lies.  In the moments where
all the lights of humanity seem to be extinguished, individuals can be their own lights
that illuminate the darkness.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...