It is quite evident, as in all of Charlotte Bronte's
works, that the theme of the position of women is society and how they are suppressed
and regarded as inferior, is a key theme in this excellent novel. From Lucy Snowe's
experiences as being penniless, friendless and isolated in a different country, it is
clear that the novel is set in a world where women are considered to be inferior to men
and are expected to act in accordance with this
belief.
However, some critics argue that the position of
women is presented much more starkly in this novel than in other works by Bronte, in
particular through the presentation of Catholic views about the position of women in
society, which worsen Lucy's vulnerable position. Even Emmanuel Paul, the man whome Lucy
falls in love with, is shown to be associated with such perspectives, as
he:
..believed in his soul that lovely, placid, and
passive feminine mediocrity was the only pillow on which manly thought and sense could
find rest for its aching temples; and as to work, male minds alone could work to any
practical result.
Note how
this view of women is patronising and supports the presentation of women in this
patriarchal society. Lucy clearly faces a massive uphill struggle, and it is perhaps
significant that she remains unsuccessful in carving a place for herself where she is
acknowledged as a woman of talent and worth, in stark constrast to Jane Eyre's eventual
victory against the forces of patriarchy.
No comments:
Post a Comment