Friday, December 12, 2014

What are 3 arguments for an essay on The Great Gatsby with this thesis about the American dream in the book? THESIS: Fitzgerald describes the...

You may wish to first alter your thesis.  For one thing,
the last phrase, "everyone comes up short in the end" is idiomatic as well as repetitive
of what the first opinion of the thesis is--the dream is "unachievable."  Secondly,
writers strive for parallelism in their theses because this structure allows the reader
to better understand each of the opinions that the writer wishes to support.  So, you
may wish to revise using three adjectives: 


In the
Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald portrays the American Dream as
illusionary,unattainable, and ultimately, destructive to
oneself.


Now, take each of these adjectives and build the
topic sentence for your 3 (sometimes more if a topic sentence needs further
development) body paragraphs.  For instance, regarding the illusionary quality of the
American Dream, you can write a topic sentence about Jay Gatsby's creation of Daisy in
his own mind.  Symbolically, he longingly stares at the green light at the end of
Daisy's pier as he imagines how their meeting after years will be.  Of course, this
meeting does not quite turn out as he has expected.  You can develop this idea
by perusing the chapter in which Nick arranges to bring Daisy to Gatsby's
house.


Likewise, with the second point of how the American
dream is unattainable, you may wish to examine the conflicts that develop in the
novel. When, for example, Daisy is frivolous and insincere; later Gatsby urges Daisy to
tell Tom that she does not love him, but she hesitates.  Then, when Mrytle is killed,
Jay Gatsby stands loyally outside her window, hoping to be able to defend her, but Daisy
plots against him with her husband Tom.  Of course, there are other supportive
incidences.


For the third point, the final chapters are the
ones you may wish to peruse.  Gatsby is destroyed by the superficiality of the people of
his age and the unreality of his dream.  The final chapter finds him alone even in
death.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...