Saturday, December 5, 2015

In episode 2 and stasimon 2 of Sophocles's Oedipus Rex, of what does Oedipus accuse Creon, and how does Creon defend himself?

In Sophocles’ play Oedipus Rex,
Tiresias tells Oedipus that Oedipus himself is the unintentional killer of his own
father, Laius, and that he has also unknowingly wedded Laius’s widow, Jocasta, who is
Oedipus’s own mother. Unwilling at first to accept the truth of Tiresias’s revelations,
Oedipus initially accuses Creon, his brother-in-law, of plotting Oedipus’s overthrow and
of using Tiresias as a tool:


readability="8">

Creon, my old trusted family
friend,
has secretly conspired to overthrow me
and paid off a
double-dealing quack . . .
 (462-64)



Later, when Creon
himself appears, Oedipus levels several charges against him, including the
following:


  • murder of Laius
    (640)

  • treason against Oedipus and a desire to replace him
    as king (641)

  • conspiracy
    (643-44)

  • cunning deception
    (646)

  • madness (648)

  • verbal
    manipulation (655)

  • being a troublemaker
    (657)

  • disloyalty to an in-law
    (663-64)

In defending himself, Creon suggests
that Oedipus is being stubborn and ignoring common sense (661-62). He defends himself
persuasively by


  • agreeing with Oedipus whenever
    Oedipus seems reasonable (667)

  • asking reasonable
    questions rather than responding in anger
    (668-69)

  • admitting any claim that is really true
    (672)

  • claiming that he only likes to talk about what he
    knows is true (685-86)

  • showing that he can ask
    reasonable, probing, relevant questions (692ff)

  • offering
    reasonable arguments to prove that he has no desire to be king
    (703-19)

  • showing the real benefits of his own current
    rank (720-24)

  • confidently challenging Oedipus to
    double-check with the oracle to make sure that Creon hasn’t lied about the oracle’s
    words (728-30)

  • stating that he is willing to be arrested
    and executed if he is lying (733)

  • asking not to be
    condemned before proof of guilt has been established
    (736)

  • reminding Oedipus of the value of their friendship
    (739-40)

  • calmly urging Oedipus to take his time
    (741)

Creon speaks very reasonably and
convincingly (unlike Oedipus), and thus it is not surprising that the Chorus Leader says
to Oedipus:


readability="7">

For a man concerned about being
killed,
my lord, he has spoken eloquently. 
(745-46)



Most readers and
audiences would clearly agree.  The fact that Oedipus nevertheless still continues to
accuse Creon shows the depth of his own irrationality.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...