Monday, April 21, 2014

Laura said, "Isn't life--" But what life she couldnt explain." What it Laura trying to say about what she thinks of life in "The Garden Party"?

This becomes one of the fundamental issues in Mansfield's
short story.  Laura is unable to explain what she considers life to be.  To a great
extent, this makes sense.  Laura has had a moment where she has seen death and
formulated impressions about it in terms of noticing the tranquility and serene nature
of the laborer's corpse.  This experience with the force of immortality, albeit brief,
is one that holds sway over her.  In a world of human constructs such as hats, garden
parties, upper and lower classes, as well as tea cups and ice cream puffs, a brief
moment with a primal force of nature that has the capacity to undermine human existence
in a brutal way causes a shift in focus and understanding.  It is here that Laura
returns having experienced some type of change.  It is not clear what that change is,
which is why she is unable to explain what "life is."  At some point, what the reader
thinks about such issues is probably where the answer lies.  If the reader believes that
a brief brush with immortality can cause change within an individual, then one will most
likely believe that Laura has changed and has become a person who will be prone to
examining being in the world through a different lens.  If one believes that such
moments do not change people, then one might be able to embrace the idea that Laura will
retreat back into her world of wealth and privilege and forget what was outside it.  In
the end, this is suspended.  We simply don't know.  We don't even know if Laura and her
brother actually understand one another and the moment that Laura experienced. All we
are left to know is that there Laura had a moment where words could not explain what was
experienced.  There is a moment, one that transcends words and language, and there is
the unknown as to what happens after it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the meaning of the 4th stanza of Eliot's Preludes, especially the lines "I am moved by fancies...Infinitely suffering thing".

A century old this year, T.S. Eliot's Preludes raises the curtain on his great modernist masterpieces, The Love...